Ads keep us online. Without them, we wouldn't exist. We don't have paywalls or sell mods - we never will. But every month we have large bills and running ads is our only way to cover them. Please consider unblocking us. Thank you from GameBanana <3

What is "Creative" and "Effort"? - A Forum Thread for Sonic 3 A.I.R.

Please just stop.

So something happened YET again in this community. Now, we don't want to become a crap fire, so let's break down what's creative and what's not first.

So skin mods, let's take two examples, both of them redesign Sonic. One changes Sonic's blues to a yellow tone, the other one changes Sonic's design so he's more akin to looking like Sonic Generations style Sonic. Now, the palette one is very simple to create. Just change some colors. Is it fun to play as? No, you're still playing boring old Sonic but he accidentally got dropped in some acid.

So how about Generations Sonic? Well, it changes the design of Sonic, it's more "Effort" to create that than the palette swap, since you need to create all the sprites and possibly even a new palette to go alongside it (while keeping the sprites) . And I see it as more fun than "Sonic but haha he's green now".

Look, it's a little disappointing that your mod got withheld/trashed. But look at it and ask your fricken self "Is it good?", think real hard about it. If the answer is no, than it's better off to leave it alone.

And hey, you can script, rawdata, and do level layout mods instead, they're more fun and mind challenging to create than green sonic. And you'll learn something out of it that could be useful in the future as well! And for those Sonic Boll-ists, there's a reason as to that rule in your domain and it's to not clog up the mod pages with "Green Sonic" or "Sonic but he has the palette of Tails".

Happy modding!
  • Kazuko259 avatar
    Kazuko259 Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    206 points Ranked 62,762nd
    5 medals 1 rare
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • 6 months a member Medal icon
    • 1 year a member Medal icon
    1y
    I like my mod its simple and fun and I want others to play it too
    Bananite
    URL to post:
  • SaievSok avatar
    SaievSok Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    96 points Ranked 42,307th
    1y
    Welp, idk if my mods can be considered good, but the people liked it and i even modded the rawdata in all of them, so tell me in your opinion if it's fair they get withelded.
    Santa Claus
    URL to post:
  • davisudo avatar
    davisudo username pic Joined 2y ago
    Not Online here
    Mushroom Modders Flag Affiliation: Mushroom Modders
    739 points Ranked 45,376th
    21 medals 1 legendary 3 rare
    • Returned 5000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Submitted 5 Tools Medal icon
    • Became a Game Pioneer Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    davisudo avatar
    davisudo
    Mushroom Modders Flag
    Affiliation
    Mushroom Modders
    1y
    i didnt start modding this game and i feel like jesus christ a chaos is starting?
    My hands are dangerous weapons avatar
    Mantra
    My hands are dangerous weapons
    URL to post:
  • SaievSok avatar
    SaievSok Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    96 points Ranked 42,307th
    1y
    i trashed my thread, trash this too and let's pretend this never happened.
    Santa Claus
    URL to post:
  • Imperfect avatar
    Imperfect username pic Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    ModdingFunkers Flag Affiliation: ModdingFunkers
    3,104 points Ranked 3,714th
    21 medals 1 legendary 4 rare
    • Returned 5000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • 10 submissions featured Medal icon
    • Reached 50 subscribers Medal icon
    • Thanked 50 submitters Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    Imperfect avatar
    Imperfect
    ModdingFunkers Flag
    Affiliation
    ModdingFunkers
    1y 1y
    so your telling me if i were to make a mod out of this it would be "low effort"
    quit modding sonic 3 air avatar
    Mantra
    quit modding sonic 3 air
    URL to post:
  • Kazuko259 avatar
    Kazuko259 Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    206 points Ranked 62,762nd
    5 medals 1 rare
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • 6 months a member Medal icon
    • 1 year a member Medal icon
    1y
    Fine I will back down it doesnt share the same beliefs I have but I know I cant change anything.

     but uh if anyone wants this to be forgotten about and placed in the past then maybe delete all the posts that started a lot of this. If you do then that probably will let me move on and just repost the new rules post so it doesnt have the comments dragging it down this part is mainly focused on mcginis so maybe also delete this one idk if everyone else agrees on this last part I just think its a way to get rid of the chaos from gamebanna.
    Bananite
    URL to post:
  • supermegakosta avatar
    supermegakosta Joined 1y ago
    call me later
    133 points Ranked 72,267th
    1y
    very informative, that are some good complains right here.
    bobux moment
    URL to post:
  • SonoDeetz65 avatar
    SonoDeetz65 Joined 2y ago
    Goner
    419 points Ranked 51,420th
    7 medals 1 rare
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback Medal icon
    • Thanked 5 submitters Medal icon
    • 6 months a member Medal icon
    1y 1y
    I'm honestly glad you made this post, thanks for clearing things up for everyone. Some people just don't know what the difference between low and good effort is sometimes, so they just go attack the rules because of it..
    Stuff happens.
    URL to post:
  • The Weigman avatar
    The Weigman Joined 3y ago
    StH (2013) Manager
    Offline
    2,494 points Ranked 20,942nd
    11 medals 2 rare
    • Achieved Game Manager clearance Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • 6 months a member Medal icon
    • Submission featured Medal icon
    1y
    Well said Airway. 
    ok
    URL to post:
  • User--27 avatar
    User--27 Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    118 points Ranked 75,473rd
    1y
    I agree. If it's just a palette swap then that's easy to do. Just pull it up in GraphicsGale and change the colors. If it has more effort, it giving the characters bigger eyes or something like that, then it should stay. I get why some people wouldn't like using Gimp, but GraphicsGale is way faster and easier.
    Bananite
    URL to post:
  • a guy on gamebanana avatar
    a guy on gamebanana Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    214 points Ranked 61,983rd
    1y 1y
    Consider the people who actually want recolours and basic mods. Let me summarize the community here in 4 sentences.

    "Hi guys this is a very faithful and cool Master System Palette, hope you-" 

    "This skin was trashed"  

    "Hi this is Angel island but orange sky and water" 

    "Mod accepted keep up the great work bud"
    Ooo wow there's "Some level design changes" wow i could have never known! What do i do with mine then? Recolour sonic red and green and ALSO change up the base levels a bit? Is THAT how recolours work now?
    Let's be honest, this modding community is a shitshow and it's all the rules' fault.
    • Agree x 1
    • Disagree x 1
    • Toxic x 1
    some idiot lol
    URL to post:
  • Blue Quacker avatar
    Blue Quacker Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    306 points Ranked 55,777th
    1y
    There goes my Playdoh Mod lmao, probably might make custom sprites for it if i ever feel like doing so. But tbh i prefer to work on better mods. Can't say i didn't took an effort with that mod tho.
    nub
    URL to post:
  • PKsoul avatar
    PKsoul username pic Joined 2y ago
    not here
    diamond sky team Flag Affiliation: diamond sky team
    539 points Ranked 48,470th
    14 medals 2 rare
    • Became a Game Pioneer Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • Became a Studio Leader Medal icon
    • Submitted 1 Tool Medal icon
    PKsoul avatar
    PKsoul
    diamond sky team Flag
    Affiliation
    diamond sky team
    12mo 11mo
    whats the problem with recolors? they have a use.
    edit: the use? THEY ARE JUST INNOCENT RECOLORS BRUH SHUT UP OR I WILL GIVE YOU A Persona 2: Eternal Punishment | Megami Tensei Wiki | FandomTHE PUNISHMENT: https://sonic3airmods.blogspot.com/
    note: joke im not giving you a punishment
    tryingtogetalmosteverymedallol avatar
    Mantra
    tryingtogetalmosteverymedallol
    URL to post:
  • Oersted avatar
    Oersted Joined 2y ago
    RPG-FES Manager PXZ2 Manager
    Offline
    1,352 points Ranked 23,857th
    17 medals 5 rare
    • Achieved Game Manager clearance Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Became a Game Pioneer Medal icon
    • Submitted 15 Mods Medal icon
    • Submitted 20 Mods Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    12mo
    why am i getting notifications for this, i dont even exist in this community
    Lucretian Knight
    URL to post:
  • Dash&Knuckles avatar
    Dash&Knuckles Joined 1y ago
    Offline
    2,312 points Ranked 21,217th
    10 medals 1 rare
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback Medal icon
    • 6 months a member Medal icon
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal icon
    11mo
    Literally everything that came up here was destroyed ... even one in which I was for a long time "Dissapointed Sonic" was not with the same name but they had done it in Sonic Mania, I based on that and...why one can stay and another not?

    I know this already seems like a complaint but I'll put another, "Blue Knuckles" Yes, it was little effort, that if I understood it, but what I did not understand is that literally someone else had already done it and had not taken off...no I'll give names but it was just really disappointing
    why this dont have GD Mods? avatar
    Mantra
    why this dont have GD Mods?
    URL to post:
  • AirWay1 avatar
    AirWay1 Joined 1y ago
    I'm sleeping.
    Team Flame Quest Flag Affiliation: Team Flame Quest
    149 points Ranked 69,639th
    17 medals 1 rare
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Returned 100 times Medal icon
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback Medal icon
    • One month a member Medal icon
    • Submitted 5 Gamefiles Medal icon
    • Submission featured Medal icon
    10mo
    Well this somehow worked out.
    Modding is Fun
    URL to post:
  • Drown avatar
    Drown Joined 11y ago
    Online
    11,149 points Ranked 643rd
    26 medals 1 legendary 3 rare
    • 10 years a member Medal icon
    • 3rd Place - Size Matters Skinning Contest Medal icon
    • 6 years a member Medal icon
    • Returned 1000 times Medal icon
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal icon
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback Medal icon
    10mo
    Who are you to decide what's fun to play and what is not ?

    If a skin is "bad" or "has no use" there won't be an audience for it. A lot of people start getting into skinning any game by doing simple stuff. Upload it, get feedback and learn -  rinse and repeat.

    The only thing that has no use is yet another discussion about recolors. There were many during the decade I have spent on here. Just be glad your favorite game is that popular. Maybe the trashing and removing is keeping the next big skinner from being motivated to contribute. 

    Remember, we are all in this for fun, the creation process and being supportive :) 
    • Agree x 2
    • Win x 2
    • Cheers x 2
    • Disagree x 2
    • Toxic x 1
    • Incorrect x 1
    In 4 teh grils. avatar
    Mantra
    In 4 teh grils.
    URL to post:
  • Yayplez avatar
    Yayplez Joined 9mo ago
    Offline
    9mo
    How do we make level layout mods? I can't seem to find a tutorial on how to do it, and if it requires some software, I would prefer it be on mac
    WOMBO COMBO!?!?
    URL to post:
  • Hee-Ho avatar
    Hee-Ho Joined 3mo ago
    Offline
    182 points Ranked 65,139th
    3mo 3mo
    "So something happened YET again in this community. Now, we don't want to become a crap fire, so let's break down what's creative and what's not first."

    meh
    Ice Fairy
    URL to post: