When is a model too detailed?

A Forum Thread for Counter-Strike: Source

Whats the rule of thumb for the amount of verticies and polygons in models used for games? I'm browsing though fallingpixel.com and wondering if some of these models would be too much for some PCs.

Posts

  • IppE avatar
    IppE username pic Joined 11y ago
    Offline
    26,499 points Ranked 167th
    21 medals 1 legendary 1 rare
    • Submitted 100 WiPs Medal icon
    • 6 years a member Medal icon
    • Skinner of the Month, June 2012 Medal icon
    • Became a Studio Leader Medal icon
    • Became a Club Leader Medal icon
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal icon
    9y
    50k is the limit where compiler goes FUBAR with source according to modderfreak. but usually ~20k or under is preferred. (more like ~5k if its lowpoly + normals) Depends on game and engine though.
    Misfortune avatar
    Mantra
    Misfortune
  • Makoto. avatar
    Makoto. username pic Joined 13y ago
    Offline
    230 points Ranked 17922nd
    9y
    Posted by IppE 50k is the limit where compiler goes FUBAR with source according to modderfreak. but usually ~20k or under is preferred. (more like ~5k if its lowpoly + normals) Depends on game and engine though.
    Close to 35k ish everything goes pretty much FUBAR, least for source (i guess you can push it to 50, but there's no point) For Goldscr it's like, what 5k? some guy was ranting about the Goldscr being able to only handle 1k on the CDG forums a while back - i don't know how much of that was true
    Hayate avatar
    Mantra
    Hayate
  • IppE avatar
    IppE username pic Joined 11y ago
    Offline
    26,499 points Ranked 167th
    21 medals 1 legendary 1 rare
    • Submitted 100 WiPs Medal icon
    • 6 years a member Medal icon
    • Skinner of the Month, June 2012 Medal icon
    • Became a Studio Leader Medal icon
    • Became a Club Leader Medal icon
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal icon
    9y
    Posted by Lenny Ray Zappa some guy was ranting about the Goldscr being able to only handle 1k on the CDG forums a while back - i don't know how much of that was true
    They have a optimization fetish there, but Goldsrc can't handle too detailed models for sure.
    Misfortune avatar
    Mantra
    Misfortune
  • Makoto. avatar
    Makoto. username pic Joined 13y ago
    Offline
    230 points Ranked 17922nd
    9y
    Posted by IppE
    Posted by Lenny Ray Zappa some guy was ranting about the Goldscr being able to only handle 1k on the CDG forums a while back - i don't know how much of that was true
    They have a optimization fetish there, but Goldsrc can't handle too detailed models for sure.
    Yeah that's why Sierra models were horrible and the unseen half was missing But meh you don't need 60 billion polygons, you can't even tell the difference between it and one that has 6 thousand or so with the skin ontop, and ingame
    Hayate avatar
    Mantra
    Hayate
  • Jailbot avatar
    Jailbot Joined 10y ago
    Offline
    363 points Ranked 12690th
    9y
    What about the Crysis engine?
    MW2 is shit, prove me wrong.
  • SGT_kick_ur_ass avatar
    SGT_kick_ur_ass Joined 13y ago
    Offline
    5,052 points Ranked 1028th
    9y
    Cry Engine can go about 40-80k polygons, but you should always avoid modeling details which can be added with the normal or ambient occlusion maps.
    Turbosmooth dat shit. avatar
    Mantra
    Turbosmooth dat shit.
  • Jailbot avatar
    Jailbot Joined 10y ago
    Offline
    363 points Ranked 12690th
    9y
    Any submissions here on the site that are over the top I could use as an example?
    MW2 is shit, prove me wrong.
  • gameripper avatar
    gameripper username pic Joined 10y ago
    Offline
    55,052 points Ranked 69th
    9y
    Most weapon view models at the end of the day will be fine under 12k. In games these days the majority of the problem comes from textures and especially on low end systems the bottleneck comes not from the polygons but from the textures.
    Team ARIA avatar
    Mantra
    Team ARIA
  • Jailbot avatar
    Jailbot Joined 10y ago
    Offline
    363 points Ranked 12690th
    9y
    So the real problem in performance is having to load so many surfaces with textures on them? Not just blank surfaces?
    MW2 is shit, prove me wrong.
  • Freaper avatar
    Freaper username pic Joined 11y ago
    Offline
    5,417 points Ranked 939th
    9y
    Well yea, and as they stated before, the bump maps also contribute to fps lag, even more when your textures are highly detailed and your model has a lot of surfaces
    Morale Pirate avatar
    Mantra
    Morale Pirate

Embed

Share banner
Image URL:
HTML embed code:
BB embed code:
Markdown embed code:

Author

Jailbot avatar
Jailbot Joined 10y ago
Offline
363 points Ranked 12690th

Jailbot
Sign up to access this!
Sign up to access this!
Sign up to access this!

Game

Sign up to access this!

Category

Share

  • Share on Reddit
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Google+

Stats

  • 1,294 Views
  • 10 Posts
  • 9y Submitted
  • 9y Modified

More from Submitter

More Customization Threads

bcp.crwdcntrl.net tracking pixel