Pros: Good image quality and border. I like the color choices you used on it.
Cons: Where is the background!? Banned Banned Banned! The cut out is a little bit choppy around the legs and the left side.
Improvements: You should add a background to the image that matches the render, try to zoom in and clean up the cut out and add a black stroke around the border or a small glow, it could use more than a gradient.
Notes: Good job, try some more with some of the Improvements I've written.
Pros: This is a fine spray, looks good in game and that is the most important thing, I guess.
The render is okay, could be better.
The quality is great really looks crisp and sleek. The pop up effect you did really makes the spray look 3D, and that's great.
The blue boarder fits well with the render.
Cons: Again, WHERE IS THE BACKGROUND? , also all 3 boarders are way to simple, try making your spray stroked with 1 black pixel and alot of c4d's that match you render's color.
The cut out is a bit choppy....
Improvements: Re-render, redo the boarder and add a damn background.
Notes: To be honest, I don't really like this spray, you made better ones.