A friend of mine (Chowder) once submitted a TF2 minigun remodel that was basically the handle and drum of the minigun with a giant pink very penis-like rotating dildo where the barrel should be. That submission was trashed. He also made a Spy knife replacement model which was just a dildo. That too was trashed.
There was also that notorious TF2 Scout Bat mod called The Thor Bat which was a uh....very large horsecock dildo. Came in several colors ranging from yellow to blue to red to natural horsecock colors. Mod is very hard to find but I of course went out searching for it and found the creator and got the models. I do believe it's in v_ and w_ model format and I did try to convert it to a c_ model myself but had no success.
I think everyone has very different definitions of NSFW, so the poll would not be very meaningful.
Personally I have nothing against exaggerated anime butts or scantily dressed models for comedic purposes. Full nudity seems outta place, imo. How about allowing to create NSFW content, but prohibit redistribution of NSFW content that you have not created yourself? This way it will not demotivate modders but will stop inflating GB with such stuff.
What's more annoying is 1/10 "WTF IS THIS MY EYES ARE BURNING" type of rates. I mean, it warned you it was NSFW and it said in the title "nude"?
I agree with tom's idea to change NSFW to explicit. Also, does this site require date of birth on registration? because I also want to suggest a feature that won't allow you to see explicit content at all until you reach a certain age (13 is not enough evidently)
In the mean time, who's up for some nice transvestite kleiner skins instead?
In a way we can now tag divisive content as NSFW that we couldn't previously. E.g edgy anime stuff (as clener74 mentioned) that is so borderline we might have trashed it before or just felt uncomfortable having it visible. Now we can just NSFW it.
What if we added a second toggle called EXPLICIT that is a step above NSFW? Such as for the nude Alyx skins.
Various other modding sites allow adult content to be hosted on their servers (to an extent; nudity is fine, but full-on sexual content is prohibited, much like how it is here), and restricting NSFW content from being posted here only limits the content that can actually be hosted here, which in turn makes some modders disinterested in posting their content here on GB. Unless the user(s) in question are somehow personally offended by the sight of nudity, which is literally a personal problem at that point, there's nothing wrong with hosting some forms of NSFW content on the site. So long as it complies with the rest of the rules on this site, we don't really have any issues with hosting NSFW content.