What do you think of Live Action game trailers vs actual gameplay footage?

Oh noes! You're not a Member!

Want access to cool stuff? As a member you can:

  • Vote. Cast your vote in the Poll.
  • View. See the poll summary and voters' choices.
  • Post. Post your thoughts regarding the Poll.
  • Stamp Posts. Let other posters know what you think of their posts.
  • Flag. Alert moderators and warn members of a problem with this Poll.
  • Subscribe. Get notified when this submitter submits again.

Interested? Register or Login

What do you think of Live Action game trailers vs actual gameplay footage?

Love em
8% (4)
Hate em
14% (7)
Really don't care
16% (8)
They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
63% (32)

Comments

  • fanerddu avatar
    fanerddu avatar Offline
    823 points Ranked 4539th
    7 medals 3 rare
    • Unlocked Treehouse VIP clearance Medal
    • One month a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 6 months a member  (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 1 year a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 2 years a member (bonus 2 points on daily login) Medal
    • 4 years a member (bonus 4 points on daily login) Medal
    • 6 years a member (bonus 6 points on daily login) Medal
    Member Joined 7 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    I feel like live action or high-end CGI trailers for games sort of help set the mood the game devs may want to be getting through to people, but it's always really cool to see them made with in-game graphics. some sort of childlike fascination with seeing some kind of cool machinima-esque video made in the actual game.

    previously sargeantwelsh avatar
    User Title
    previously sargeantwelsh
  • pjsas avatar
    pjsas Offline
    1,458 points Ranked 2659th
    7 medals 2 rare
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal
    • Unlocked Treehouse VIP clearance Medal
    • One month a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 6 months a member  (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 1 year a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 2 years a member (bonus 2 points on daily login) Medal
    • 4 years a member (bonus 4 points on daily login) Medal
    Member Joined 4 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    depends if it comes close to the actual game.

  • R E X avatar
    R E X Offline
    Member Joined 4 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    What I really hate is when a game company makes a trailer and it is nothing like the game itself, where the trailer uses higher poly models, better textures, and everything.

     avatar
    User Title
  • Devieus avatar
    Devieus avatar Offline
    49,823 points Ranked 72nd
    Moderator Joined 5 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    I don't mind them, but people should remember they're secondary to the game; it's like have people read a book during a movie trailer, it could provide extra background and exposition, but it shouldn't be integral.

    The most important to me is the HUD and the gameplay sequences so I can understand the mindset I'm supposed to be in a bit.

    Sentinel of the TV remote avatar
    User Title
    Sentinel of the TV remote
  • ShiHan avatar
    ShiHan Offline
    6 medals 1 rare
    • Became a Studio Leader Medal
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback (bonus 1 point for posting) Medal
    • One month a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 6 months a member  (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 1 year a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 2 years a member (bonus 2 points on daily login) Medal
    Member Joined 4 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    Posted by Ganryu

    Posted by ShiHan Coincidence that this ends when the world ends?

    Don't believe in that crap, dude. The world was supposed to end in the year 1996, yet we're still here. It was then supposed to end in the year 2000, but again, we're still here.

    Back on topic: I honestly don't care if it's live-action footage or gameplay footage, I prefer to play the game itself to get my own opinion of it. If I like the gameplay, I'll continue to play it. If not, then I'll either give it to someone else or trade it in for another game.

    I know its not going to end, was supposed to in 1986 apparently, and again in 1999, 2006 blah blah blah. I knew it'd get someones attention though >:D .

    Anywho live action trailers are good, but seeing the actual in-game trailer does help in answering some questions that people have about said game.

    Master of Loading avatar
    User Title
    Master of Loading
  • Ganryu avatar
    Ganryu
    Helpful Toastie
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    Posted by ShiHan Coincidence that this ends when the world ends?

    Don't believe in that crap, dude. The world was supposed to end in the year 1996, yet we're still here. It was then supposed to end in the year 2000, but again, we're still here.

    Back on topic: I honestly don't care if it's live-action footage or gameplay footage, I prefer to play the game itself to get my own opinion of it. If I like the gameplay, I'll continue to play it. If not, then I'll either give it to someone else or trade it in for another game.

    • Agree stamp iconAgree x 1
    • Win stamp iconWin x 1
  • ShiHan avatar
    ShiHan Offline
    6 medals 1 rare
    • Became a Studio Leader Medal
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback (bonus 1 point for posting) Medal
    • One month a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 6 months a member  (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 1 year a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 2 years a member (bonus 2 points on daily login) Medal
    Member Joined 4 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    Coincidence that this ends when the world ends?

    • wtf stamp iconwtf x 1
    • Funny stamp iconFunny x 1
    Master of Loading avatar
    User Title
    Master of Loading
  • deadman22 avatar
    deadman22 avatar Offline
    2,518 points Ranked 1486th
    Member Joined 7 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    I like Live action trailers to a certain extent, but if it's going to be for a game I would much rather see gameplay footage. Just makes more sense to me.

    Everyone is Dead avatar
    User Title
    Everyone is Dead
  • Drown avatar
    Drown Offline
    1,260 points Ranked 3056th
    9 medals 2 rare
    • Reached 1,000 Points Medal
    • 1 post awarded Exemplary Feedback (bonus 1 point for posting) Medal
    • 5 posts awarded Exemplary Feedback (bonus 2 points for posting) Medal
    • 10 posts awarded Exemplary Feedback (bonus 3 points for posting) Medal
    • One month a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 6 months a member  (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 1 year a member (bonus 1 point on daily login) Medal
    • 2 years a member (bonus 2 points on daily login) Medal
    • 4 years a member (bonus 4 points on daily login) Medal
    Member Joined 5 years ago
    • Report icon
    3 years ago:

    They often are really atmospheric and give the game and game descriptions available more depth

    Worth going to hell for. avatar
    User Title
    Worth going to hell for.

Votes

  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • Love em
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • Hate em
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
    Squeezit Sixth Dimension Flag
    Sixth Dimension
  • Really don't care
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • Hate em
    3 years ago
  • Really don't care
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • Really don't care
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • Really don't care
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
  • They're okay, so long as some footage is available.
    3 years ago
    4Echo avatar
    4Echo
    Destiny Flag
    Destiny

Submitter

Logan Dougall avatar
Logan Dougall avatar Offline
33,212 points Ranked 121st
Half Life Storm Flag Affiliation: Half Life Storm
Admin Joined 9 years ago

Logan Dougall avatar
Logan Dougall
Half Life Storm Flag
Half Life Storm

Stats

Votes
51
Last Day to Vote
December 21st 2012
Post Count
9
ViewCount
3,291
Date Added
3 years ago
Date Modified
3 years ago

Share

Embed HTML:
Embed BB Code:
Embed Markdown:

More embeddable images

Bookmark and Share