GAMEBANANA: Justified rating remover (Ideas)

Justified rating remover

(

Home

> Ideas

> Justified rating remover

)

Suggestion: Justified rating remover

A little bit of inception (and irony)

As all bananites know. Whenever someone rates and never comments, It can freely be deleted.
However if a comment is added, you can't remove the rating (unless done by the rater).

What if the rating was of pure hatred, or ignorance. AND commented as well.
What now?
You'd have to complain to a Moderator or to the user itself. I find this annoying. And I think the moderators wouldn't like this as well.

I want to suggest an option to delete "justified" ratings.

Before deleting a "justified" rating. The owner of the submission MUST justify his complaint

Grounds for removal:
Reason is irrelevant to the actual content (exaggerated example: "The usp model is bad" on an awp skin)
Hate vote (e.g. "i rated one, because f*ck you")
Grounds for preservation:
Comment shows personal opinion relevant to subject and accurate on content
The complaint must be reviewed by a moderator.
Moderator deletes or keeps the rating accordingly.
Pro:
No more complaints in the comment sections of each users profiles (and moderators as well)
Calms my OCD
Con:
More work for moderators -_-

Resolution: Unknown

Ratings

Lightning Storm loves this	9 months ago
Liney loves this	10 months ago
Troopster loves this	10 months ago
Username Logan Dougall greatly dislikes this	10 months ago
Username LightningCyan loves this	10 months ago
Anonymous is undecided about this	10 months ago
HEAVYS_SANDVICH likes this	10 months ago
Blur. likes this	10 months ago
HylianWolf dislikes this	10 months ago
XFree loves this	10 months ago
Defunct Account loves this	10 months ago
Pro3z loves this	10 months ago
Username simple rule 02516 dislikes this	10 months ago
gallowsCalibrator loves this	10 months ago
CafeRev is undecided about this	10 months ago
Username Teh Thrasher loves this	10 months ago

Comments

Page:

RomZ's Levels
- P1: Beggar
  Points: 390
- E1: Helper
  EF: 11
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 4 years
RomZ
Posted 10 months ago
Posted by Logan Dougall

Two options:

A) Support Button, bottom of every page.

B) Report Button, on every post and submission page.

Neither requires knowing who/where moderators are and/or collecting their Personal IM/Email contact info to try and reach them (besides, one should use PM's and just c/p userid numbers).

you win
But i'd still would've liked a more prepared style of doing this.

User Title
Slacking off
Logan Dougall's Levels
- P5: Peddler
  Points: 143,374
- E6: Authority
  EF: 223
- C5: Admin
- A6: Elder
  Account Age: 7 years
Username
Logan Dougall
Posted 10 months ago
Two options:

A) Support Button, bottom of every page.

B) Report Button, on every post and submission page.

Neither requires knowing who/where moderators are and/or collecting their Personal IM/Email contact info to try and reach them (besides, one should use PM's and just c/p userid numbers).
- Win x 1
!MOVING! Contact another Admin
RomZ's Levels
- P1: Beggar
  Points: 390
- E1: Helper
  EF: 11
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 4 years
RomZ
Posted 10 months ago
Posted by Logan Dougall

Contact a moderator

I was expecting you'd say that
once again, i don't like disturbing them though :(
aside from that, other moderators hide the options with regards to contacting them in their profiles
(though maybe this can be solved by editing the url)

The idea I was hoping for was a more organized way of complaining to moderators the bad "justified" ratings.
Though, I am aware of the bias on the owner's side. But that's where the moderator's judgement comes in.

They'd still intervene with the whole removal process (i put it in the idea), but in a more organized manner. And not by contacting personally.

User Title
Slacking off
Logan Dougall's Levels
- P5: Peddler
  Points: 143,374
- E6: Authority
  EF: 223
- C5: Admin
- A6: Elder
  Account Age: 7 years
Username
Logan Dougall
Posted 10 months ago
Contact a moderator

Post in their profile, create a support ticket, send an email etc. Eventually use the dedicated appeals process (in progress), but it all boils down to contacting a moderator.

This is what they are for. They know the rules/limitations and can make the appropriate decisions on what are and are not good posts/ratings. Users should not be able to delete all ratings at a whim.

I'm sorry, but authors are biased when it comes to their own work. This is why even moderators cannot moderate their own content, they have to have others do it for them.

!MOVING! Contact another Admin
Defunct Account's Levels
- P2: Drudge
  Points: 1,449
- C1: Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 2 years
Defunct Account
Posted 10 months ago
Finally someone understands!!

Twice has someone came and out of spite and anger rated my stuff low.
This needs to be implemented STAT!
RomZ's Levels
- P1: Beggar
  Points: 390
- E1: Helper
  EF: 11
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 4 years
RomZ
Posted 10 months ago
Posted by jc980

Kinda a bad idea. Since newbies would take advantage of this by deleting some of the real "justified" ratings.

That's why it should be reviewed by the moderator first.
I guess they can suspend this option if he becomes annoying and illogical.

Posted by THE-DESTROYER

(resubmitting old stuff issue)

I think they shouldn't be rating it bad if their reason is simply because you resubmitted it.
You shouldn't be angry though, you didn't make those stuff. If it really is not so good, accept it that way.
I'm not against you in resubmitting old stuffs though.

User Title
Slacking off
Teh Thrasher's Levels
- P3: Peasant
  Points: 20,444
- E1: Helper
  EF: 1
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 2 years
Username
Teh Thrasher
Posted 10 months ago
Posted by RomZ

Posted by THE-DESTROYER

VERY GOOD IDEA! I WANNA REMOVE THAT GODDAMN BAD RATINGS (ENEV IF THEY ARE JUSTIFIED). I DON'T GIVE A FUCK ABOUT THEIR NEGATIVE OPINION.

But that's not the essence of the option. It should serve as to regulate the supposed "justified" ratings yet irrelevant to the actual content.

If your submission is relatively awful, take consideration the negative stuff they stated and improve the skin next time.

"take consideration the negative stuff they stated and improve the skin next time", BUT I AM JUST RESUBMITING THE OLD STUFF THAT WAS LOST WITH THAT FUCKIN' GUY NAMED "MunZz". I AM JUST TRYING TO HELP THE BANANA AND THEY ARE JUST SOME FUCKIN' INGRATE GUYS THAT RATE MY SKINS BAD 'CUZ I AM DOING GOOD WORK.

EDIT : ALSO I AM IN DOUBT THAT THE OLD CS 1.6 SECTIONG WILL RETURN. I WANT THIS SO MUCH BUT I DON'T THINK THIS IS POSSIBLE.THAT'S THE REASON WHY I AM REUPLOADING ALL THE OLD STUFF.
- Disagree x 1
User Title
You're on a Psycho Holiday.
jc980's Levels
- P1: Beggar
  Points: 726
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A3: Apprentice
  Account Age: 1 year
Username
jc980
Posted 10 months ago
Kinda a bad idea. Since newbies would take advantage of this by deleting some of the real "justified" ratings.

User Title
Psycho-Pass
simple rule 02516's Levels
- P2: Drudge
  Points: 3,125
- E1: Helper
  EF: 1
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A2: Tenderfoot
  Account Age: 12 months
Username
simple rule 02516
Posted 10 months ago
U could just report unfair rating to the mods

User Title
Next Generation of Gamebanana
RomZ's Levels
- P1: Beggar
  Points: 390
- E1: Helper
  EF: 11
- C2: Treehouse Member
- A4: Graduate
  Account Age: 4 years
RomZ
Posted 10 months ago
Posted by THE-DESTROYER

VERY GOOD IDEA! I WANNA REMOVE THAT GODDAMN BAD RATINGS (ENEV IF THEY ARE JUSTIFIED). I DON'T GIVE A FUCK ABOUT THEIR NEGATIVE OPINION.

But that's not the essence of the option. It should serve as to regulate the supposed "justified" ratings yet irrelevant to the actual content.

If your submission is relatively awful, take consideration the negative stuff they stated and improve the skin next time.

User Title
Slacking off